UPSC CSE Prelims 2024

Indian Polity Notes Class-2 "Basic Structure Doctrine"

Basic Structure Doctrine’s Evolution

  • Contest between:-  Article 13 (Laws that violates FR can be declared null and void) and Article 368 (Power of Parliament to amend the Constitution)
  • Between Supremacy of Judiciary vs Parliament
  • Locus → Judicial interpretation of Land Reform Laws 
  • Contest between :-
    • Community Rights: Land Acquisition vs Individual Right to Property 
    • Supremacy of Parliament vs Supremacy of the Judiciary 
    • Fundamental Rights vs Directive Principles of State Policy 
    • Socialistic Policies: Land Reforms vs Capitalist Policies: Large Estate 
    • Liberty vs Equality

What are some important Articles / provisions with respect to the Judgements

  • Art. 13(2) → law that violates rights in Part III → null & Void
  • Art. 368 → Procedure and Power to Amend Constitution 
  • Art. 39(b), 39(c) → Equitable distribution of wealth & prevention of wealth in Hands of few 
  • 9th Schedule → Added by 1st CAA; exempted from Judicial Review

Shankari Prasad vs Union of India

  • Can Parliament Amend Constitution?
  • Article13 → Any law that takes away Part 3 shall be void
  • Outcome: Amendment NOT ordinary Law; Parliament Can Amend C / Takeaway FR 
  • Article 368 > Article 13; Parliament > Judiciary

Sajjan Singh vs State of Rajasthan

  • Context : 17th CAA → Property can be confiscated even if it violates Article 14, 19, 21
  • Article13 → Any law that takes away Part 3 shall be void
  • Upheld the verdict of Shankari Prasad [ 368>13]

Golaknath vs State of Punjab

  • Context: 1st CAA, 4rth CAA, 17th CAA 
  • Outcome #1 → Parliament has no power to abridge of take away FRs ; [ Art 368 > Art 13] 
  • Outcome #2 → Constitutional Amendment = ordinary law ; restricted under Art. 13(2) 
  • Outcome #3 – Art 368 only provides procedure of amendment; does not confer power to amend 
  • Govt Reaction → 24th CAA ; Article 13(2) not applicable to CAA [ 368>13]

Keshavananda Bharti vs State of Kerala

  • Context: Land Acquisition under Kerala Land Reforms Act
  • Outcome #1 → Recognized Parliament Power to Amend Any Part of Constitution/ Art 368 = procedure + power to amend Constitution. 
  • Outcome #2 → Constitutional Amendment = ordinary law; restricted under Art. 13(2) 
  • Govt Reaction → 24th CAA; Article 13(2) not applicable to CAA [ 368>13]


Raj Narain Case vs Indira Nehru Gandhi

  • Context: Raj Narain → Indira Gandhi → Electoral malpractice → Election Void 
  • Govt Reaction → 39th CAA → No Power to decide on Electoral Disputes 
  • Judgement #1 → Power to Amend Constitution Accepted, Pass Laws with retrospective effect 
  • Govt Reaction → Swaran Singh Committee & 42nd CAA

42nd CAA – Mini Constitution

  • 31C: Laws to implement 39(b)&(c) DPSP not void if violates FRs → changed to “ANY” DPSP
  • All past amendment & future amendment → not within scope of judicial review

Minerva Mills vs Union of India

  • What happened? Minerva Mill → nationalized (private property → public / national property)
  • Case moved from → infringement of fundamental right → wider questions of Parliament’s power to amend 
  • Judgement #1 → 31C Amendment null & void; harmony b/w FR and DPSP → basic feature 
  • Judgement #2 → power to Amend is a limited power

Waman Rao vs Union of India

  • What happened? Private Property & Land Acquisition Case in Maharashtra; placed in 9th Schedule
  • Judgement #1 → Acts placed in 9th Schedule after Keshavananda → within Judicial review 

Conclusion 

  • Power to Amend → Limited Power, subject to basic structure 
  • 9th Schedule → Subject to Judicial Review
  • Power to Amend → Take away Fundamental Rights 

Post a Comment

Cookie Consent
We serve cookies on this site to analyze traffic, remember your preferences, and optimize your experience.
Oops!
It seems there is something wrong with your internet connection. Please connect to the internet and start browsing again.
AdBlock Detected!
We have detected that you are using adblocking plugin in your browser.
The revenue we earn by the advertisements is used to manage this website, we request you to whitelist our website in your adblocking plugin.
Site is Blocked
Sorry! This site is not available in your country.
//disable Text Selection and Copying